Heroes - any good?

edited November 2009 in Chit chat
The TV series. I'm considering watching it.
Post edited by BigBadMick on

Comments

  • edited November 2009
    the first series is good, as it's like all these real people who develop super powers but still have to have normal lives.

    the second series is shit, and it goes down hill from there. the problem is they kept trying to reinvent the same characters every series.

    worth a watch but don't expect it to get better as it goes on.
  • edited November 2009
    Personally I think the first season was great. Everything since then has been downhill.
    I still watch it, but I don't really enojoy it anymore. It usually leaves me annoyed.
    Website: Tardis Remakes / Mostly remakes of Arcade and ZX Spectrum games.
    My games for the Spectrum: Dingo, The Speccies, The Speccies 2, Vallation, SQIJ.
    Twitter: Sokurah
  • edited November 2009
    Loved the first series. Got rapidly annoyed with the second, and dropped it. Apparently it's gotten worse since. So yes, grab the first series by all means... but don't be tempted to go further :)
  • edited November 2009
    Sokurah wrote: »
    Personally I think the first season was great. Everything since then has been downhill.

    Couldn't agree more. First series was surprsingly good, then it quickly became garbage when they fiddled about with what type of show it was about. Where I differ with Sokurak is that I stopped watching..couldn't stand it eventually.
    I stole it off a space ship.
  • edited November 2009
    Yep... I liked the first series too. Erm, but that's about it.
  • edited November 2009
    The novelty didn't really grab me because I've read graphic novels before, so the presentation styles weren't new to me.

    The first series' finale was a damp squib.

    The second series was crap.

    Didn't bother after that, but crap reviews all round.

    If you've read many graphic novels before, avoid, but if you haven't then it might be worth a look.
  • edited November 2009
    NickH wrote: »
    The novelty didn't really grab me because I've read graphic novels before, so the presentation styles weren't new to me.


    If you've read many graphic novels before, avoid, but if you haven't then it might be worth a look.

    what a wierd review. :-P

    what other show should comic fans avoid?
  • edited November 2009
    mile wrote: »
    what a wierd review. :-P

    Not really - Heroe's strength is with the style, rather than the plot. If you're familiar with the style already, then it won't impress you at all.

    And to think the sharp, stylish and intelligent "Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip" got cancelled midway through its first series, and yet this pap got a third (fourth?) series says everything you need to know about American culture these days.
  • edited November 2009
    mile wrote: »
    what a wierd review. :-P

    what other show should comic fans avoid?

    I think I can see what NickH was getting at. As a comic book reader, watching all the TV reviewers and pundits go nuts over Heroes season 1 made me feel like a super-evolved alien watching a bunch of monkeys oook and honk at the black monolith. "OMG it has so many characters! And flashbacks!" Yes, you dumb shits, when you've finished gurning you will find us waiting for you on a higher evolutionary plane, where we've had stories this complex for decades. :)

    And to keep up the comic-book metaphor, after the initial rush of excitement it's gotten bogged down in stupidly over-convoluted continuity, new writers not understanding what's gone before, story arcs ruined in the quest to keep things rolling, and pointless resurrections :D
  • edited November 2009
    Danforth wrote: »
    And to keep up the comic-book metaphor, after the initial rush of excitement it's gotten bogged down in stupidly over-convoluted continuity, new writers not understanding what's gone before, story arcs ruined in the quest to keep things rolling, and pointless resurrections :D

    Sing it, bro.

    I stopped getting the compilation graphic novels for Batman when it turned into Buffy. I'd kill Robin again if I could because the independent Batman was the best. The other franchises don't really interest me, but the movies based on Alan Moore's(?) work (V for Vendetta, Sin City, etc) really work for me.
  • edited November 2009
    NickH wrote: »
    Sing it, bro.

    I stopped getting the compilation graphic novels for Batman when it turned into Buffy. I'd kill Robin again if I could because the independent Batman was the best. The other franchises don't really interest me, but the movies based on Alan Moore's(?) work (V for Vendetta, Sin City, etc) really work for me.

    Yeah, but they don't work for him. He hates the lot of them.

    Sin City was Frank Miller by the way. The other Alan Moore films are Watchmen, From Hell and The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen.
  • edited November 2009
    NickH wrote: »
    Not really - Heroe's strength is with the style, rather than the plot. If you're familiar with the style already, then it won't impress you at all.

    i wouldn't of said that, it was the characters that captured the imagination imo. at the end of the day spiderman, superman etc are for children. but these characters had more adult problems so people could connect to them more.

    not saying all comics are for kids, some are done for adults, but there not as accesable as a tv show.

    what i think happened is they tried to make it more like xmen or something like that and ended up making it shit. they shoud have kept all the powers low key, and not have them saving the world every series.
  • edited November 2009
    Matt_B wrote: »
    Yeah, but they don't work for him. He hates the lot of them.

    Sin City was Frank Miller by the way. The other Alan Moore films are Watchmen, From Hell and The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen.

    Aha... TLoEG was *very* cool.
  • edited November 2009
    mile wrote: »
    i wouldn't of said that, it was the characters that captured the imagination imo. at the end of the day spiderman, superman etc are for children.

    Some of them are. Some of them definitely aren't - especially some of the bloodier stories. People get killed, tortured, maimed, and quite graphically, too. You'd have to be a pretty shocking parent to put one of the graphic novels which had a gang rape in to one of your children. The children's versions are the exception rather than the rule, I'd say.
  • edited November 2009
    NickH wrote: »
    Some of them are. Some of them definitely aren't - especially some of the bloodier stories. People get killed, tortured, maimed, and quite graphically, too. You'd have to be a pretty shocking parent to put one of the graphic novels which had a gang rape in to one of your children.

    and that just the bash street kids. :lol:
  • edited November 2009
    Pretty much agree with everyone else. First series superb. Second lost the plot. Third regained it for a bit then lost it again. Fourth looked like it might regain it but succumbed to stupid plot lines. I never got the Ali Larter role in S3 and 4.
  • edited November 2009
    So what IS a good tv series to watch?

    At the moment I'm considering:

    House
    24
    Prison Break
    Flash Forward

    Just trying to come up with a good series to watch after catching up on Lost.
  • edited November 2009
    BigBadMick wrote: »
    So what IS a good tv series to watch?

    At the moment I'm considering:

    House
    24
    Prison Break
    Flash Forward

    Just trying to come up with a good series to watch after catching up on Lost.

    House is superb.
    24 no idea.
    Prison Break S1 is superb (watched about 1/2 of it so far), but I hear past S1 are soso)
    Flash Forward. Struggled to stay awake through episode 1.

    ymmv.
  • edited November 2009
    NickH wrote: »
    Aha... TLoEG was *very* cool.

    I wouldn't disagree.

    Moore's dissatisfaction with the films based on his work is probably far more because he's a control freak than because of any flaws in how they were adapted.
  • edited November 2009
    Unlike everyone else I still like it.


    Prison break is better though if you didn't see it and that had a proper ending.
  • edited November 2009
    BigBadMick wrote: »
    So what IS a good tv series to watch?

    I've mentioned it a couple of times in the past, but Fringe (same creator as Lost, JJ Abrams) is good and at times absolutely bloody brilliant. The latest episode is one of the best episodes of a tv program I've ever seen.

    The Wire IMO is an absolute must for anyone. By a mile the greatest TV program I've ever seen.

    Dexter has been consistently excellent. Season 3 was a belter.

    Breaking Bad is supremely well written and stars the fantastic Bryan Cranston (Malcolm in the Middle's dad - another recommendation - my favourite ever american comedy).
Sign In or Register to comment.