A question for Beatles fans

2»

Comments

  • I like Disc one of the White Album. It's great to listen to all the way through.
    Disc two is where it falls apart for me.

    They could've spiced it up with Hey Jude and Lady Madonna.
  • edited November 2011
    Oh and Paul McCartney's Ram's as good as anything the Beatles did. One of the best album's ever!

    YEAH.

    but i disagree about what you people are saying about the white album.

    the white album is different from the others even because of the "uncensored" flow of creativity that went into it, included the jokes, the weird tracks, the collages and the whatevers. without of all these monstruous agglomerate of everything and anything, it would have been the usual polished album in which everything must be as it should be.
    as it is, it's a strange travel in which you can encounter the most sublime or the most strange characters (i mean the songs). it makes it far more interesting and far more funny.
    i like wild honey pie.
  • edited November 2011
    Oh and Paul McCartney's Ram's as good as anything the Beatles did. One of the best album's ever!

    Of the Wings/McCartney albums that I have listened to, my personal favourites are "Band on the Run", "Venus and Mars", and "McCartney", they are all excellent albums in my opinion, the first two are just as good as most Beatles albums. The great shame is that John Lennon was supposed to be joining Wings for "Venus and Mars", but he ducked out at the last minute.

    Another favourite is John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, what a raw album that is.

    Not a big fan of All things must pass, but I do like Ringo, the nearest we ever got to a full reunion.
  • edited November 2011
    Another White Album fan here. I normally even listen to Revolution No 9.

    I'm not a big fan of Revolver personally. It has some great tracks on it, but I prefer Rubber Soul.

    AHDN is the definitive Merseybeat era Beatles album.
  • edited November 2011
    Revolution 1 (The Hey Jude B-Side was definitive)
    yes, agreed. white album version just sounds lazy in comparison

    someone has upped the entire thing on one youtube vid, havent actually heard it in a few years. probably not the ideal way to listen to it but my cassette copy is no doubt in some jumble sale bargain bin now

  • edited November 2011
    lol I competely forgot how terrible O Bla Di O Bla Da is :lol:
  • edited November 2011
    def chris wrote: »
    yes, agreed. white album version just sounds lazy in comparison

    Definitely lazy. It was the do I/don't I hypocrisy of the White Album version that bugged me.
    Revolution 1 (White Album)
    "When you talk about destruction, don't you know that you can count me out, in" (followed by irritating doo-wopping!)

    Revolution (Hey Jude B-Side)
    "When you talk about destruction, don't you know that you can count me out..." (followed by genius fuzz-guitar licks which caused dipsticks to return the single cos they thought something was wrong with it!)

    Wonder which version Lennon preferred, and why he felt the need to add 'in' to Revolution 1 (which I believe came after the B-Side, although again I may be wrong.) Was he trying to appease the peacenik hippy movement or his own conscience? Or both...
  • edited December 2011
    I prefer the B side version, the white album version was quite a surprise the first time I heard it.
  • zx1zx1
    edited December 2011
    One of my favourite tracks on the White Album is 'Helter Skelter' and another is 'Happiness is a warm gun'.
    The trouble with tribbles is.......
  • edited December 2011
    Not so keen on Helter Skelter, although it is good. I love Happiness is a Warm Gun though.
  • edited December 2011
    Let It Be was a strange hodgepodge of live and produced tracks, but out of it comes four absolute killer songs, all indisputable classics: "Get Back" (US No1, No1 for six weeks in Britain), "Across The Universe"(regarded by Lennon as one of his best songs ever), "Let It Be" (the album version is far better, not least because it contains THAT guitar solo, and Prince's all time favourite song, US No1) and "The Long And Winding Road"(below par arrangement, but absolutely brilliant songwriting, with one of the most perfect middle eights in history, US No1). Their previous few albums don't have four tracks as big as those.
    THE RETRO GAMER IRC CHATROOM. EVERY SUNDAY AT 9PM BST. LOG ON USING THE LINK BELOW:
    https://discordapp.com/invite/cZt59EQ
  • edited December 2011
    Personally I don't like Across the Universe. I think it's pretty mediocre for Lennon and rather self indulgent.
  • Alien 8 wrote: »
    Personally I don't like Across the Universe. I think it's pretty mediocre for Lennon and rather self indulgent.

    I don't like it either. The version on Past Masters is better but still not great.

    Let It Be is great though and I've got a feeling is so underated.
  • zx1zx1
    edited December 2011
    Spector wrote: »
    Let It Be was a strange hodgepodge of live and produced tracks, but out of it comes four absolute killer songs, all indisputable classics: "Get Back" (US No1, No1 for six weeks in Britain), "Across The Universe"(regarded by Lennon as one of his best songs ever), "Let It Be" (the album version is far better, not least because it contains THAT guitar solo, and Prince's all time favourite song, US No1) and "The Long And Winding Road"(below par arrangement, but absolutely brilliant songwriting, with one of the most perfect middle eights in history, US No1). Their previous few albums don't have four tracks as big as those.

    And you sir. wasted 'The long and winding road' with your overblown choir and ochestra!:lol:
    The trouble with tribbles is.......
  • edited December 2011
    I don't like it either. The version on Past Masters is better but still not great.

    Let It Be is great though and I've got a feeling is so underated.

    I just love "I've Got a Feeling", but personally I think the Past Masters version of Across the Universe is even worse than the regular one. Let It Be is great though, one of the best McCartney ballads ever.
  • edited December 2011
    A free electronic book entitled the Yellow Submarine has just been released on iBooks by Apple. I am downloading it to my iPod Touch now but it is slow. It must be in demand. It has lots of clickable music links. Also links to film and animation extracts (some voiced by Dick Emery).

    I am not a big Beatles fan but remember seeing the film at Gants Hill Odeon in 1969. There was a big police presence and they also had the local karate club out. And there was me in my mauve paisley embossed corduroy jeans and dylanesque floral shirt. Peace Man.
  • Woah! Showing your age there! :D
  • edited December 2011
    Gants Hill Odeon is not even there anymore. It was demolished about 10 years ago now.
  • zx1zx1
    edited December 2011
    He must be nearly as old as Karingal:smile:
    The trouble with tribbles is.......
  • edited December 2011
    Alien 8 wrote: »
    Personally I don't like Across the Universe. I think it's pretty mediocre for Lennon and rather self indulgent.
    I think it sounds terrible. I prefer the first version I heard - Fiona Apple recorded a cover for Pleasantville, with a video using some continuous-shot trickery based around the movie.
    Joefish
    - IONIAN-GAMES.com -
  • edited December 2011
    zx1 wrote: »
    He must be nearly as old as Karingal:smile:
    Older, I was 5 in 1969...
    I wanna tell you a story 'bout a woman I know...
Sign In or Register to comment.