Value for money?

edited December 2008 in Chit chat
As part of the misses christmas present I bought her "Professor Layton and the Curious Village" on the DS. This was after she had seen it advertised on TV and mentioned it would be nice if she got a copy.

After managing to find a copy, not easy, sold out everywhere, which means they must have sold a few, I gave it her and then promptly borrowed it to play myself.

I finished it in 12 hours with 100 of 120 of the puzzles solved (you don't need to solve them all to finish the game) so I still have a small amount of play in it but is 12 hours (of which at least an hour, probably 2, are taken up with watching non-skipable storyline bits) good value for money?.


How much game play would you expect to get out of new game?, no use of guides or anything like that allowed.

P.S. A very good game if you like puzzle games - recommended - Excellent use of the DS touchscreen
Post edited by ADJB on

Comments

  • edited December 2008
    a workmate got me to stick it on his flashcard a while back, he said he failed to solve the first puzzles twice
    Professional Mel-the-Bell Simulator................"So realistic, I found myself reaching for the Kleenex King-Size!" - Richard Darling
  • edited December 2008
    How much was this game? Doesn't sound like great value for money to me, but then again is it a game that you could go back and redo? Do the puzzles change significantly enough? I don't really play modern games very much so I've not got much to compare it to.
  • edited December 2008
    The game was ~£30

    As far as I can tell the puzzles don't change and although some of them have multiple answers (or ways of getting to the answer) overall it seems static and linear in format.

    At a guess I would say the longest any single problem took me was 20mins, I didn't think any of them were very hard but I suppose its aimed at brats as the main market so you don't want them too difficult.

    Edit - Thinking about it you probably spend a lot more than my initial guess of a couple of hours watching the videos, there is a lot of text in it.
  • edited December 2008
    I think you should measure your value by how much you enjoyed it. It sounds to me that you did as you played a full 12 hours and will probably go on to complete the rest of it. You may also be super good at puzzle games.

    Personally, I like games to have short attainable goals these days rather than having to devote 80 hours to a Final Fantasy game. I usually just give up on big games and hardly ever complete them. I think the last big game I finished was either Halo or Shenmue 2.
  • edited December 2008
    WhizzBang wrote: »
    I think you should measure your value by how much you enjoyed it. It sounds to me that you did as you played a full 12 hours and will probably go on to complete the rest of it. You may also be super good at puzzle games.

    Personally, I like games to have short attainable goals these days rather than having to devote 80 hours to a Final Fantasy game. I usually just give up on big games and hardly ever complete them. I think the last big game I finished was either Halo or Shenmue 2.
    yeah i like value for money BUT i also dont have much time to devote to games these days so i prefer short blasts of say mario kart or tetris rathert han playing games like resi evil or zelda.......even tho i love those games too, i just cant play em very often so forget what im doing etc
    Professional Mel-the-Bell Simulator................"So realistic, I found myself reaching for the Kleenex King-Size!" - Richard Darling
  • edited December 2008
    I've been playing the resi games so long I'm even good at new ones when they come out, I have to stop myself from finishing them too quickly (with the exception of 4 which was rock to start off with, but once I got used to it I was flying) :D

    Saw a trailer for a CG Resi Movie on TV yesterday called Resident Evil: Degeneration. Originally I thought it was an ad for a new game, Leon looks just like he did in Resi 4 and it has what looks like Claire in it as well. So basically it'll be like watching a Resi game you can't play. Not sure if that's a good idea really :D

    Wonder if the voice actors will be the same people from the games?

    Hijack over :D
    Every night is curry night!
  • edited December 2008
    my GF thought it was a great game. when i do buy games it either has to look like something i will either play for ages, have a lot of replay value or just want to eperience.

    30 quid for 12 hours doesn't sound bad when you usually pay 12 quid for a 2 hour DVD. or 6 quid for a 2 hour movie in the pictures. or 50 quid for an hour with an eastern european girl.

    the only game i have completed on the 360 is fallout 3, and that took me 70 hours, not counting myself playing through it again to make those different choices in the storyline.

    must say though i don't judge all games on the time played, it has to be the experience as someone else mentioned before.
  • edited December 2008
    I guess it depends on the age group the game is aimed at. A grown man completing a kiddies puzzle game in 12 hours is shocking, which ever way you look at it.
  • edited December 2008
    One thing worth saying about this game is its one of the best "transport" games you will find.

    You can save at any time and if you just have a 5 minute bus ride just look at 1 puzzle with no loss. Non of this stupid "finish the level before you can save" stuff.

    I wouldn't say I'm particularly good at puzzles but being an engineer by training it automatically means I'm used to problem solving on the fly which no doubt helps.
  • edited December 2008
    I've been playing the resi games so long I'm even good at new ones when they come out, I have to stop myself from finishing them too quickly (with the exception of 4 which was rock to start off with, but once I got used to it I was flying) :D

    Saw a trailer for a CG Resi Movie on TV yesterday called Resident Evil: Degeneration. Originally I thought it was an ad for a new game, Leon looks just like he did in Resi 4 and it has what looks like Claire in it as well. So basically it'll be like watching a Resi game you can't play. Not sure if that's a good idea really :D

    Wonder if the voice actors will be the same people from the games?

    Hijack over :D
    yeah i downloaded that resi evil degeneration film a while back, not watched it yet but ive glanced through it and it does look like a game.
    Professional Mel-the-Bell Simulator................"So realistic, I found myself reaching for the Kleenex King-Size!" - Richard Darling
  • edited December 2008
    It was a joke!

    Of course, it could be said that all games are aimed a kiddies! I too studied engineering (at college) and built an engine as part of my exams. It didn't work too well though cos I was crap at tapping threads and everything went wonky!
  • edited December 2008
    frobush wrote: »
    I guess it depends on the age group the game is aimed at. A grown man completing a kiddies puzzle game in 12 hours is shocking, which ever way you look at it.

    I would say the puzzles vary from incredibly easy (at the start) to downright evil in places.

    I'll post a couple to give examples but a forum isn't a good place to try and reproduce a DS touchscreen puzzle.

    1, XXXXX - XXXX = 33333
    replace the X's with the numbers 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 & 9 so the sum works.

    2, You have eight weights, 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 & 8.
    All except one of the weights are the same. The odd weight is lighter than the others.
    You also have a simple balance scale.
    By using the scale no more than twice how do you tell which is the light weight.

    There are many other types of puzzle like sliding block type puzzles but you just cant represent those here.
Sign In or Register to comment.