Why no contender to the Minecraft throne?

edited December 2012 in Chit chat
The game has a huge fanbase, i don't play it myself byt my son plays it all the time. With countless CoD clones isn't it odd noone tried to copy Minecraft?

I think a more direct interaction between objects would work even better than the way objects now interact to each other. You have to make most of new stuff on the workbench. A more "Boulder Dashish" way. Realistic flow of water and waterlevels would also be great. And animals that don't just spawn behind your back.

Yeah, Boulder Dash in 3D!
Post edited by MinerWilly on

Comments

  • edited December 2012
    Like infiniminer? :)

    Not exactly a clone of course... :p
  • edited December 2012
    The XboxLive Indie section has half a dozen or so Minecraft "clones". They all came out before Minecraft was anounced and at least one of them has made it's developer a small fortune. Although, he claims that his game has "nothing what so ever to do with Minecraft" other than it being almost exactly the same ;-)

    Although this may not be the one I'm thinking of with the above statement, it'll give you an idea of how much these clones "borrow"

  • edited December 2012
    I've never played Minecraft properly - I tried it briefly but it did nothing for me. To be fair, I know I didn't give it a proper try, for the same reason that I've never played World of Warcraft; I don't want to get addicted. WOW and Minecraft are the two games that are most connected with gaming addiction (from what I've read on the 'net, and I have two friends who are WOW mad, one all but abandoned all other games about four years back, and still lives for WOW).

    Anyway, a quick Google for

    minecraft type games

    shows lots of similar games, but I can't comment on any of them.
  • edited December 2012
    I've heard allot about mine craft, but have not played it yet. What exactly is it?

    From what i understood is sort of a "lego" game with Doom kind of graphics that for some reason people enjoy playing in 2012...

    Am I close?
  • edited December 2012
    VanTammen wrote: »
    I've heard allot about mine craft, but have not played it yet. What exactly is it?

    From what i understood is sort of a "lego" game with Doom kind of graphics that for some reason people enjoy playing in 2012...

    Am I close?

    Yes, at least as far as I understand it. You can basically build anything in an infinite area (at least it's infinite insofar as most people would bother exploring it), but you have to find/manufacture certain types of block, and if you play the 'survival' (or whatever it's called) mode, then at night creatures come out to hunt for you, so you have to have built a safe dwelling during the day.

    Anyone who's played the game for more than five minutes, or who's played anything later than the beta I tried, can no doubt add much more to the above description, but I will add that to me these games, and the Lego builder games, are no fun as the thing about Lego in real life is that it's tactile, you touch it, and building Lego blocks (or equivalent) on-screen is no fun at all, to me.

    I'm not talking about the Lego Batman, Lego Harry Potter, etc, games, as they are action games, not building games.
  • edited December 2012
    guesser wrote: »
    Like infiniminer? :)

    Not exactly a clone of course... :p

    Isn't infiniminer the game that minecraft is based on?
  • edited December 2012
    LEGO Universe should have been good competition but it got ruined by poor management of the project. The original aims got lost along the way. I do remember seeing a physics-based game where you could build a city with virtual LEGO bricks, then demolish it with FPS weapons. But I don't think it ever got further than the basic single-player sandbox.
    Joefish
    - IONIAN-GAMES.com -
  • edited December 2012
    The XboxLive Indie section has half a dozen or so Minecraft "clones". They all came out before Minecraft was anounced and at least one of them has made it's developer a small fortune. Although, he claims that his game has "nothing what so ever to do with Minecraft" other than it being almost exactly the same ;-)

    Although this may not be the one I'm thinking of with the above statement, it'll give you an idea of how much these clones "borrow"


    yeah he even complained when the official minecraft game came on the arcade saying it wasn't as good as his version.

    as for large companies doing it, i assume they dont want to be seen as ripping off a small popular software firm.
  • edited December 2012
    1980-20.. wrote: »
    Isn't infiniminer the game that minecraft is based on?

    Correct
  • edited December 2012
    guesser wrote: »
    Correct

    And that was the point you were making i see :oops:
  • edited December 2012
    Not played it. Only seen vids and references made on here.

    Can't be missing much I guess.

    Well, I do remember someone made a comment here about how someone had made a Z80 "emulator" (or something similar) in Minecraft, which sounded impressive, I guess.

    Soooo ... Does that indicate the potential for a Speccy emu in Minecraft? ( :razz: )
  • edited December 2012
    ZnorXman wrote: »
    Not played it. Only seen vids and references made on here.

    Can't be missing much I guess.

    Well, I do remember someone made a comment here about how someone had made a Z80 "emulator" (or something similar) in Minecraft, which sounded impressive, I guess.

    Soooo ... Does that indicate the potential for a Speccy emu in Minecraft? ( :razz: )

    I think the "something similar" was a 16-bit register. Not having done computer science in 20-odd years it's probably as close to a Speccy emulator as I'm ever gonna know what the hell
    I'm talking about.
  • edited December 2012
    Minecraft is ace! It's basically like playing with lego, but with added survival horror and explosions!!

    And you can explore the lands that are created and find hidden treasure and mine into dungeons filled with rare minerals to let you build even more things!

    At night, all the monsters appear outside too and try to hunt you down, so you need to build a shelter to hide from them until morning or get a sword or bow and arrow and kill them!

    And you can build minecart rides!! And saddle a pig! And grow crops...and make intricate mechanisms to open a door....or visit another dimension full of lava and more horrible beasties!!!

    Go on...give it a bash and keep your inner 7 year old happy! :D



    Oh, and that guy who ripped off Minecraft with the XBL Indie game made more than just a small fortune! He's now a millionaire!!!
  • edited December 2012
    So there are more. But they seem all to be quite simple. What i really would want is water that act like water. It would add a lot if you would be able to build dams and stuff!
  • edited December 2012
    Minecraft is easily one of the most absorbing games I've ever played and probably the closest we've come to the ideal of sandbox gaming yet. It's also proof that gameplay trumps graphics (the graphics are actually quite primitive, especially with the default textures).

    One major criticism is that there's as much "work" as play because you have to dig mines and chop down trees. All that's true but it just makes the construction side of things more satisfying and adds to the survival aspect. And if you want to just build there's a construction-only mode on the PC version.

    Another criticism was that, like Colony, there was no real point to the game beyond what goals the player set themselves. This has been rectified and there's an in-game quest that involves finding a stronghold, activating a portal in it, reaching a dimension called "The end" and defeating a final boss. As with all good sandbox games whether the player decides to follow the main quest is entirely up to them.

    Oh, and there's absolutely no narrative at all, a plus in my book. ;)
  • edited December 2012
    Zagreb wrote: »
    And if you want to just build there's a construction-only mode on the PC version.

    This was brought to the xbox360 version too in a title update.
    Zagreb wrote: »
    Oh, and there's absolutely no narrative at all, a plus in my book. ;)

    Absolutely! This is one of the countless paths where modern games gone wrong. A book should be a book, a movie a movie and a game a game!
Sign In or Register to comment.